How To Beat Unfair Mental Health Funding

I happened to be talking to my local politician before Christmas because a fine website on depression, www.DepressioNet.com.au was about to lose funding for its crucial 24 hour support forums as a result of failure by the Australian government to fund its programs.

So I pinged the pollies and Bill, my local politician, wanted to chat. The one illuminating aspect of our 45 minute conversation was that it was very hard (for politicians) to decide what other health programs should be cut in order to increase funding for mental health because of myriad vested interests.

Watching news reports around the world and back home I see similar difficulties arising. It is somewhat reminiscent of the Yes Minister dilemmas that Sir Humphrey Appleby would put to his boss, thereby stymieing him every time.

Just last week in South Australia an identical furore erupted. There, the government was brave (or hassled) enough to announce increased mental health funding. The opposition was equally mean enough to demand to know what (more highly valued) general health programs were to be sacrificed for the increase. Read the report here: http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200601/s1545360.htm

Now to get back to Yes Minister, Jim Hacker in his early days would have said But we should just fund health needs according to the cost to the community, the individual and the carer. And that should be the minimum amount needed to restore the ill persons health so as to function in relationships, at work and in the community. You wish!

The unfairness is obvious when authoritative reports state: Stigma is systemic in decision-making at the highest political levels. Ultimate responsibility for mental health services lies with government leaders at Federal and State levels.

It is they who have ensured these services have had such a low priority in policy-making and funding

The proportion of Australias health budget spent on mental health services is under 8%. In comparable OECD countries, the proportion is 12% or more. Dare to Care, SANE Mental Health Report 2004 at http://www.sane.org/images/assets/Research_reports_and_images/MHR2004text.pdf

A report by Access Economics for SANE Australia in 2003 calculated the costs of bipolar in Australia as being $16,000 on average per year for each sufferer. Yet spending is only $3,007 per person.

It gets worse. The report states that this paltry $3,007 is even less than spending on the average Australians health care, even though the burden of disease the pain, suffering, disability and death is greater for bipolar disorder than for ovarian cancer, rheumatoid arthritis or HIV/AIDs, and similar to schizophrenia and melanoma.

And who makes up the shortfall? According to the report, around half (i.e. $8,000) of this cost is borne by people with the illness and their carers.

Mentally healthy public outnumber the mentally ill by a factor of 4 to 1. They want their subsidized spas and perfect teeth at the expense of us getting into hospital when we need it! But because they still view the behaviors of mental illness as not symptoms but as plain bad behavior, our health needs are viewed as less deserving than theirs, and funded accordingly.

Because of the Yes Minister factor, I think we face an uphill battle persuading the politicians. They wont shift until public opinion does, to say nothing of favors and kickbacks.

The 4 people in 5 who dont have a mental illness have something much worseprejudice. They are the ones who need persuading that mental health deserves equitable funding.

Australians who want to get involved in dismantling stigma can get involved in SANE Australias StigmaWatch program at http://sane.org/index.php?option=displaypage&Itemid=266&op=page

Visit www.twotreesmedia.com/links for other organizations around the world.

You can read a summary of the Access Economics report Bipolar Disorder: costsan analysis of the burden of bipolar disorder and related suicide in Australia, an Access Economics Report for SANE Australia 2003 at http://www.sane.org/images/assets/Research_reports_and_images/bipolar_costs_es.pdf

Madeleine Kelly is the author of the award-winning book Bipolar and the Art of Roller-coaster Riding (Two Trees Media ISBN 0-646-44939-7). More information about managing bipolar disorder can be found at http://beatbipolar.com.

Mental Health
It would appear that at some point after World War I, real mental health became something of a luxury. The absence of any real mental disease like schizophrenia or dementia certainly is not an indicator of complete mental health any longer. The boom in knowledge of human psychology that began in the 1960s has made that eminently clear.Truthfully sp...

Mental Health Services
It is an established fact that almost two-thirds of all people afflicted with some kind of mental dysfunction do not seek treatment. This is confirmed by the WHOs Global Burden of Disease study.The reasons for that people do not seek treatment vary, but some of the most common ones are a fear of the social stigma attached to mental disease; a fear ...

Suicide Prevention Through Better Mental Health Care
Better mental health care and ease of access :We need to find ways to make life less difficult for people who struggle with mental illness. No one should have to choose between needed medicine and food or shelter. We all deserve to have our basic needs met with respect and acceptance. Mental illness is not the persons fault any more than cancer or...

Locating Local Mental Health Services
When someone realizes they may be suffering from a mental health issue it can be overwhelming trying to determine where to turn for help. Most communities offer services to people suffering with mental health conditions.Some of these services are offered free via grants from the government and its important that those afflicted know where to turn w...

A Quick Guide To Mental Health Care
More and more people are afflicted with mental health issues today. The incidence of mental problems has risen gradually over the last decade as a direct result of the lives we lead. Everyone in society is stressed, rushing around constantly and has no time at all to relax. Depression can set in as a result of this or of a dissolved marriage, a dea...

The Fourth Cardinal Sin of Thinking: The Unfair
Life is unfair. There are no declarations, contracts, scriptures or any such writings which proclaim life to be fair. And yet, for some reason, most people believe life is supposed to be fair, reliable, predicable. Its somewhat understandable when children scream out thats unfair! But, as adults, its somewhat juvenile that we continue to hold on t...

Oregon Personal Injury Funding
Personal injuries can result in either bodily or mental harm. If you, as a victim choose to take the help of the Law for recovering damager, it can mean a long legal battle. Most people use their personal money to fight personal injury cases and soon they are exhausted of all financial resources. They are also intimidated by large insurance compani...